DALLAS, TX—The Texas 5th Court of Appeals has ruled in favor of the Dallas County Commissioners Court in a lawsuit brought by the Dallas County Juvenile Board that challenged commissioners’ control of the county budget.

The case arose from the Commissioners Court’s request for treatment records related to juvenile detainees following allegations that children were being confined in cells for up to 23 hours a day. Commissioners refused to approve the Juvenile Board’s budget and salary increases until the requested records were provided, prompting the Juvenile Board to file suit in state district court. The Commissioners Court filed a procedural motion challenging the district court’s jurisdiction to hear the case, which was denied, and appealed that decision to the 5th Court of Appeals.

On appeal, Mr. Baruch argued that the Commissioners Court acted within its authority, emphasizing that the lower court’s ruling improperly considered political motives outside its jurisdiction. The Court of Appeals dismissed claims that the Commissioners Court violated the Texas Open Meetings Act and rejected the Juvenile Board’s attempt to seek retroactive salary payments.

In addition, the ruling upheld the trial court’s dismissal of subsequent claims against Judge Jenkins and Commissioners Garcia and Sommerman.