Tony Box: A Different Kind of Lawyer

“I’m a different kind of lawyer,” says Tony Box, partner at Gray Reed. His statement refers not only to his commitment to the law and his clients, but also to his surprisingly diverse career path. Box has served as an investigator and prosecutor in financial cases (he is a licensed CPA), an agent for the FBI, and a judge advocate general (JAG) attorney. He was the target of a murder-for-hire hate crime and as a teenager was shot in the stomach trying to help the victim of an attempted robbery.

These and other experiences have shaped what he calls a holistic view of life. “I try to keep an open mind and remember that people go through difficult situations,” he says. “They make mistakes, but they are still human beings, and they deserve to be treated with dignity and respect, always, every time. Regardless of their circumstances, they are still human.”

Currently Box represents businesses and individuals in all types of civil and criminal tax cases, white-collar defense cases, regulatory investigations and enforcement actions. He represents U.S. and international clients across a wide range of industries, including healthcare, technology, energy, real estate, construction, and manufacturing.

When asked about his notable cases, Box does not dwell on the numerous cases where he obtained positive results for his clients who were defrauded or were facing government investigations. Instead, he mentions a remarkable case from his career in the government, which provided Box and his team with the opportunity to help free an innocent man who had spent 28 years behind bars.

By then, I had long since left the Circuit Attorney’s Office, but I was in Lamar’s corner, which was also the corner of justice. And after 28 years of being wrongfully imprisoned, Lamar finally walked free."

Fighting in the Corner of Justice

Lamar Johnson was convicted of murder in 1995. He always maintained his innocence stating that he was with his girlfriend at the time of the killing. His conviction was based primarily on the eyewitness testimony of one person.  As a result of Box’s efforts, on February 14, 2023, Circuit Judge David Mason ruled that evidence presented constituted “clear and convincing” proof of Johnson’s innocence.

Box, with the circuit attorney’s office, learned of the case and of allegations that the key witness had been paid for his testimony. Box believed reviewing the case had merit. He and his team talked to Johnson’s attorneys and decided to open their own investigation. The prosecutor in the case denied that the witness had been paid. Box had access to all the internal files and quickly found evidence of payments to the key witness. He immediately sent the information to Johnson’s attorneys. The Circuit Attorney’s Office filed a motion to for a new trial and after a lengthy litigation battle, they won.

“I testified on Lamar’s behalf,” Box says. “By then, I had long since left the Circuit Attorney’s Office, but I was in Lamar’s corner, which was also the corner of justice. And after 28 years of being wrongfully imprisoned, Lamar finally walked free. He’s a good man, and now he’s a friend.”

His deep concern for others, and his willingness to put himself on the line, first showed itself when he was just 16 years old, working as a bagger at a local grocery store. One afternoon, while helping a customer carry her groceries to the car, a thief suddenly grabbed the woman’s purse and took off running. Without hesitation, Box gave chase. His high school football training kicked in, and he caught up to the thief, who then pulled out a gun and shot him.

The bullet remains lodged in his liver to this day. Remarkably, after recovering, he returned to the same job. He often said that working as a grocery bagger was one of the best ways to grow up and learn responsibility.

“You meet all kinds of people in all kinds of situations. And eventually I worked my way up from bagger to cashier in a couple of years, I was really proud of that,” he says.

CPA, JAG AND FBI

Box joined the FBI and served as a special agent for nine years. His focus was primarily on white-collar crime. He also trained as a forensic computer examiner, developing highly technical investigative skills that would later shape his legal career.

During his time with the Bureau, agents uncovered a murder-for-hire plot targeting him. A white supremacist was recorded using slurs and discussing payment for Box’s death. The threat was so serious that the FBI offered to relocate him and his family, but he declined, determined to finish the cases he was working and raise his family in a stable community.

Box says one of the most valuable lessons he learned at the FBI was how to truly listen to and read people, especially when they aren’t being honest. “I’m pretty good at telling when someone’s lying to me. As a lawyer, I work every day with clients and witnesses who may not want me to know the full story. I rely heavily on the skills I learned at the FBI,” he says.

While serving as a special agent, Box attended law school at night. Encouraged strongly by his wife, he decided to pursue a career in law, which was a path that allowed him to combine analytical skill with public service.

His legal practice is strengthened by the fact that he is also a licensed CPA with deep experience handling complex, high-dollar financial matters. As a senior investigator for a Big Four accounting firm, he traveled globally to address financial issues at multimillion- and billion-dollar companies.

“I understand balance sheets, income statements, cash-flow statements — virtually every financial element of a case,” Box says. “Few attorneys can say that. The numbers are like a second language to me.”

Box also served twice in the U.S. Army. His military journey began in college, when he joined ROTC his freshman year. After graduation, he became a tank commander and later served in Iraq and Afghanistan. When he applied to the FBI, he faced a difficult choice because agents could not remain in the Reserves, so he stepped away. After earning his law degree and completing his FBI service, he returned to the Army as a JAG officer, becoming part of what is often called “America’s oldest law firm.”

“Really, I was a force multiplier,” Box says. “I helped combat soldiers do their jobs by removing the legal worries occupying their headspace. That’s where I discovered the joy of truly helping someone through the law, and I carry that into my work today.”

Box receiving special agent credentials with FBI Director Louis Freeh in January 1997, Quantico, VA.
Box-tony
Box preparing for mission flight in Iraq in 2011.

The Job Is to Do Justice

Box went on to serve as both a state prosecutor, including leading a conviction integrity unit, and a federal prosecutor with significant experience in white-collar crime. “People don’t always realize this, but the real role of a prosecutor is not to get convictions, it’s to do justice. And sometimes doing justice means walking away from a bad case, even if you’ve worked on it for years,” he says.

Like many new prosecutors, he began handling drug, gun, and violent-crime cases. “You’re in court constantly. You stand on your feet, you argue, and eventually the butterflies go away,” he says. Over time, he transitioned into white-collar and tax-related prosecutions, where his CPA background gave him a distinctive advantage.

Box says, “When I was a prosecutor, I wasn’t a conviction-at-all-costs guy. I understood that people sometimes make terrible choices — and they should be punished. But punishment should also be fair. If the law allows 10 years, but you don’t believe the person will reoffend, maybe three years is enough to teach the lesson.”

Life Goes On

Box leads an eclectic life out of the office. He has aged past playing football or basketball, but has developed a love of running. He finds more than just the fitness angle in the sport, something that benefits his work life as well as his personal life.

“It’s good to know that I’ve still ‘got it,’ that I can force myself to do hard things. When you can take on big challenges, when you see you can do hard things, it makes a world of difference in your outlook and how you approach life. I’ve seen people who are generally afraid to fail, and they never get the thrill of doing hard things. That’s where you really build your confidence.”

His reading generally focuses on biographies, political biographies, and business books. He listens to political and current events podcasts. He enjoys listening to jazz, R&B and he is a big fan of modern country and western music.

Box says his life has been to say the least diverse, but one that has and continues to be challenging, rewarding and exciting. “I have lived a life of service, that’s number one, as an individual who is dedicated to service, and that’s what wakes me up in the morning and what I think about before going to bed at night.”

At a Glance

Gray Reed
1601 Elm St, Ste. 4600
Dallas, TX 75201
(214) 954-4135
www.grayreed.com

Education

Professional Experience

Military Experience

Honors

Community Involvement